Consumers' adoption of the Kindle

E-mail Print PDF

Diffusion of Innovations

A few days ago, The Atlantic ran an article titled “The Kindle Problem.” In it, author Kevin Maney gives his thoughts on why many consumers have not yet purchased one of Amazon’s e-readers. His basic premise is that when developing products, companies should focus on either providing an excellent experience or being extremely convenient -- but not both. He states:

...in aiming to provide both a great experience and supreme convenience, [the Kindle] has achieved neither. And unless it can be revamped to truly distinguish itself, either as the best reading experience around (superior to the old-fashioned book), or as the cheapest and most convenient reading outlet available, it may be doomed to fail.

Maney continues by stating that Amazon’s pursuit of both elements has required the company to charge a price too high for the majority of consumers. While this has some merit, such a view is far too simplistic to be useful. After all, those companies following Maney’s advice have sold far fewer devices than has Amazon.

This is not to say that price does not matter. It does. Price undoubtedly has an impact on purchase decisions. However, as Everett Rogers describes in his research and in his book “Diffusion of Innovations,” consumers’ adoption of innovation is impacted by numerous factors. According to Rogers, a new innovation’s rate of adoption can largely be explained by five variables: the perceived attributes of the innovation, the type of innovation decision, the communication channels used, the nature of the social system, and the extent of change agents’ efforts.

Within these five variables, Rogers identifies the perceived attributes as being most significant. These attributes -- relative advantage, compatibility, complexity, trailability, and observability -- together tend to explain anywhere form 49 to 87 percent of variation in consumer adoption of a new innovation.

When interpreted through this framework, Maney’s argument centers around the Kindle’s relative advantage, with a heavy focus on economic costs. However, Maney’s focus on these costs does not include proper attention to perceived benefit or to the other sources of relative advantage. Rogers states:

Diffusion scholars have found relative advantage to be one of the strongest predictors of an innovation’s rate of adoption. “Relative advantage” is a ratio of the expected benefits and the costs of adoption of an innovation. Subdimensions of relative advantage include economic profitability, low initial cost, a decrease in discomfort, social prestige, a saving of time and effort, and immediacy of reward.

In other words, consumer behavior cannot be explained through a dichotomous product development strategy of providing experience versus convenience.

Comments (3)add comment

p90x said:

...
Swiss Replica Watches
Hublot Watches
Porsche Design Watches
Richard Mille Watches
Rolex Watches
TAG Heuer Watches
U-Boat Watches
Vacheron Constantin Watches
Zenith Watches
P90X Workout DVDs
P90X Workout
P90X
P90x reviews
August 28, 2010 | url

mbt shoes said:

...


coach bags, coach bags
vibram shoes, vibram shoes
chanel bags, chanel bags
MBT Shoes, MBT shoes

August 30, 2010 | url

moncler discount said:

...
cheap uggs
ugg tall boots
UGG Shoes
UGG classic boots
ugg boots cheap
I've never given much thought to how I would die, but dying in the place of someone I love seems like a good way to go.
I only said it’d be better if we weren’t friends, not that I didn’t wanna be.
Try first to make their mistake sound less serious and then to reduce it to nothing at all.
Good news never goes beyond the gate, while bad news spread far and wide.
On festive occasions more than ever one thinks of one's dear ones far away.It is on the festival occasions when one misses his dear most.
Paul Smith Men's Wallets
discount mbt shoes
chi sale
moncler polo
moncler outlet
September 04, 2010 | url

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
 

Scott Lowe

Scott Lowe

 

Book lover and recent MBA graduate living in NYC.

Read more

Search

Tweet! Tweet!

An error occurred

Oops, an error seems to have occurred. We're sorry for any inconvenience this might have caused. If the error persists, feel free to tell us about it.

Sml's  book recommendations, reviews, favorite quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists
You are here: Home Consumer behavior Consumers' adoption of the Kindle